MANUAL OF UNITARIAN BELIEF
by JAMES FREEMAN CLARKE
have no creed, and as their union is one of sympathy and co operation,
and not of formulas, no one among them has any right to define the views
of others. A Manual such as this is meant simply to express what,
in the opinion of the writer, is the general belief of the majority of
Unitarians. Every proposition contained in it is liable to discussion,
correction, and revision. No one is bound by it; and it does not
attempt to limit thought, but rather to stimulate and rouse inquiry.
It is intended
to be made the theme of discussion, and to help the teacher of the class
in the Sunday-school, by furnishing, for himself and his pupils, topics
for examination. To this end questions are added at the close of
each Lesson, and references are given to passages of Scripture.
RELIGION NECESSARY TO MAN.
§ 1. RELIGION
may be defined as the worship and service of God. It is necessary,
because man is feeble, and needs Divine power to give him strength; he
is ignorant, and needs Divine light to guide him; he is sinful, and needs
Divine mercy to give him peace; he is mortal, and needs faith in things
unseen and eternal to give him the hope of continued existence.
§ 2. That
religion is natural to man appears from the fact that in a higher or lower
form it has been found among all races and nations, among civilized and
savage people, in ancient and modern times.
§ 3. The
following elements in the soul constitute the basis of religion; namely,
the sense of dependence (see § 1.); conscience, or the sense of right
and wrong, giving the ideas of duty and responsibility; reason, or the
faculty which perceives universal and necessary laws; * aspiration, which
tends toward the good, the beautiful, and the true, and is the basis of
§ 4. Natural
religion is that which is awakened by the sight of the order and beauty
of nature, of its adaptations to the use of living beings, of its variety
and unity; leading the mind up to the conception of a Supreme Being, perfect
in power, wisdom, and goodness.
§ 5. Revealed
religion consists of the revelations of Divine truth made to the souls
of inspired men, thus producing lawgivers, prophets, and spiritual leaders
for the human race.
§ 6. Christianity
is the religion taught by Jesus and his Apostles, as recorded in the New
Testament. Founded by Jesus, this religion has continued to the present
time, and is still the faith professed by those nations of the world which
are most advanced in civilization.
§ 7. All
those born and educated in Christian lands are Christians; as all born
and educated in England are Englishmen, and in America are Americans.
Without our own choice we receive an influence from the circumstances and
institutions which surround us in childhood and youth. We are unconsciously
educated by Christian institutions into certain habits of Christian thought
and feeling. When we read the life and teachings of Jesus
we find in them what feeds the moral and spiritual nature, and satisfies
the highest needs of the soul. We then believe consciously and experimentally
in him, because he helps us to be good and to do good.
When we are able to
compare the character and truth of Jesus with those of other teachers and
masters, ‹ as Moses, Confucius, Buddha, Mohammed. Socrates,‹if we
find in him a greater depth and fulness of spiritual life than in any other
we shall believe intellectually in him as the best of teachers and masters.
§ 8. The
two great divisions of the Christian Church in this country are the Protestant
and the Roman Catholic. Unitarians believe Protestantism to be more
in accordance with the teaching of Jesus, and we also find it more frequently
associated with free thought, social progress, and liberal institutions.
§ 9. Unitarians,
strictly speaking, are those Christians who reject the Church doctrine
of the Trinity, and do not believe that Jesus is God the Son, equal with
the Father, or that he is the Supreme Being.
Unitarians also usually
agree in rejecting the system of doctrines known as Orthodox, as we shall
see in the course of this Manual. As these doctrines constitute a
logical system, of which the doctrine of the Trinity is the keystone, when
that is removed the arch falls.
§ 10. Those
who accept the Unitarian belief should openly profess it and should unite
in Unitarian churches, because, if we believe that Jesus was not the Supreme
Being, and that he taught that he was not, we are bound to testify openly
to this conviction. If, according to Christ and his Apostles, there
is no such God as the "Trinity," it must be wrong to appear to worship
this God, who is unknown to the Scriptures of the New Testament.
Moreover, it has been found that wherever Unitarian churches are established
they become centres of movements in behalf of education, philanthropy,
and social reforms.
§ 11. Unitarians
regard the Bible as a sacred book because full of the utterances of inspired
souls. It brings us near to God by placing us in communion with the
deepest and loftiest experiences of mankind.
§ 12. We
believe the Bible to be an inspired book because it is full of the thoughts
which come to men by inspiration. The Psalms, the Book of Job, Isaiah,
the writings of Paul, and the words of Jesus were not the result of pure
thinking, but came from a region higher than the reflective reason.
§ 13. But,
though considering it an inspired book, Unitarians also regard the Bible
as coming not only from God, but also from man. It is full of human
experience, sorrow, joy, temptation, sin, repentance, trust, hope, love.
Coming from the deepest places in man's heart, it goes to the deepest places.
It has its heights and depths, its lofty mountain-tops and its level barren
plains. It is human, there fore fallible. Written by many men
and at different times, it is of very various application and value.
There is little that is edifying for us in the Book of Leviticus or the
Book of Revelation. Our Bible opens naturally not there, but at the
Psalms, the Sermon on the Mount, the parables of Jesus, the ardent utterances
of the soul of Paul.
§ 14. Unitarians
do not believe in the infallibility of the Bible. Inspiration leads
to the sight of truth and reality, but not necessarily to a perfectly accurate
description of what is seen. But these errors of expression do not
detract from the authority of the Bible as a teacher of the best moral
and spiritual truth.
§ 15. Unitarians
also see a difference in the moral and religious teaching of different
parts of the Bible. The Old Testament teaches a different doctrine
from the New in regard to God, duty, and immortality. The truth unfolds
itself gradually to human eyes; and the human race may say, as Paul said,
"When I was a child, I spake as a child, I felt as a child, I thought as
a child; now that I am become a man, I have put away childish things" (
1 Cor. xiii.II ). The Unitarian objections to the
doctrine of plenary or infallible inspiration of the Scripture are such
as these: (a) The Scripture nowhere claims or assumes infallibility.
The texts usually relied on (2 Tim. iii. 16 and 2 Peter i.
21) teach that the Prophets and Apostles were inspired, but do not assert
that their inspiration made them infallible.
(b) The Scripture contains errors and contradictions which are
fatal to the theory of its infallibilty. But if its authority consists
in its being more full of truth and goodness than any other book, then
its errors of detail cannot shake its divine power over the mind and heart.
(c) The Apostle Paul distinctly declares the partial, provisional,
and temporary nature of that which he teaches. Having said (I Cor.
ii. 10-16) that he is inspired and led by the Spirit to know and
to speak Christian truth, he adds, in the same Epistle (I Cor. xiii.
8-12), that all knowledge, so far as we are able to state it, is partial,
relative, and incomplete, and will be done away.
BELIEF CONCERNING GOD.
§ 16. Unitarians
believe that God is one,‹one being and one person. They believe that
he is infinitely wise, holy, and good; that he is omnipotent and omnipresent;
that his highest attribute is love, and that his best name is "Father."
The Unitarian belief concerning God can be expressed in the words of the
New Testament. For example, (a) As regards his
unity. Mark xii. 29. Jesus answered, "The
first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel; the Lord our God is one
Lord." I Cor. viii. 4: "We know . . . there
is none other God but one." I Cor. viii. 6: "To us there is
but one God, the Father." Gal. iii. 20: "God is one." I Tim.
ii. 5: "For there is one God, and one Mediator between God and men,
the man Christ Jesus." Eph. iv. 6: "One God and Father of all,
who is above all."
(b) That this one God is the Father. John xvii. 3.
Jesus, praying to the Father, says, "This is life eternal, that they might
know thee THE ONLY TRUE GOD, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.
John x. 29: My Father, which gave them me, IS GREATER THAN ALL .
John xiv. 28: I go unto the Father; FOR MY FATHER IS GREATER THAN
(c) That God the Father is almighty, omnipresent, and omniscient.
Acts xvii. 27: The Lord is "not far from every one of us; for in
him we live, and move, and have our being." I Cor. viii. 6:
"One God, the Father, OF WHOM ARE ALI I HINGS. 1 Cor. xv.
28: When all things shall be subdued unto him. then shall the Son
also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, THAT GOD
MAY BE ALL IN ALL. Rom. xi. 36: For of him, and through
him, and to him are all things." Eph. iv. 6: "Who is above
all, and through all, and in you all."
(d) That God is essentially love, and that he loves all his creatures,
both bad and good. 1 John iv. 16: "God is
love, and he that dwelleth in love dwelleth in God, and God in him." Matt.
v. 44-45: "Love your enemies . . . that ye may
be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun
to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on
the unjust." I John iv. 8: "He that loveth not knoweth not God; for
God is love."
§ 17. The
doctrine of the Trinity, as stated in the creeds of all the so-called Orthodox
churches, is this: that there are three persons in the Godhead,‹ the Father,
the Son, and the Holy Ghost,‹and that these three are one God, the same
in substance, equal in power and glory, but distinguished by personal properties.
The Athanasian Creed is the most distinct formula of this doctrine.
It says: "The Catholic faith is this, ‹that we worship one God in Trinity,
and Trinity in Unity, neither confounding the persons nor dividing the
substance. For there is one person of the Father, another of the
Son, and another of the Holy Ghost. But the Godhead of the Father,
of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost is all one; the glory equal, the majesty
co-eternal." This doctrine teaches that the Father is God, the Son is God,
and the Holy Ghost is God; and yet there are not three Gods, but one God.
Each may be worshipped separately. Each has a separate work and office,
which must not be confounded with that of the others; for that would be
the heresy of Sabellius, who confounded the persons. But we must
not say that they are three persons, like Peter, James, and John; for that
would be dividing the substance, which is another fatal heresy.
See the "Westminster
Assembly's Catechism," which is the creed of the whole Presbyterian church;
the Athanasian Creed, still read or sung, by authority, four times a year
in the Church of England; the Augsburg Confession; and the creeds of other
Orthodox denominations. § 18. Unitarians reject
the Church doctrine of the Trinity,‹ (a) Because it is unintelligible.
Although many attempts have been made to explain it, none have proved satisfactory.
It therefore remains, even by the admission of its advocates, a mystery;
and a mystery is something unintelligible, and therefore cannot be an object
(b) Because the doctrine of the Trinity is nowhere plainly taught in
the New Testament. This is admitted by many candid Trinitarians.
Thus, Neander, a Trinitarian, says of this doctrine: "It is expressly held
forth in no one particular passage of the New Testament." (Church History,
Torrey's translation, vol. i. p. 572.) Many such testimonies
might be adduced. (c) Because the texts quoted in support
of the Trinity are inadequate or irrelevant.
The famous text of the Three Witnesses has been shown so convincingly
to be an interpolation, that it has been rejected by most Trinitarians
and omitted in the Revised Version. The Baptismal Formula (Matt.
xxviii. 19) and the Benediction (2 Cor. xiii. 14) are
passages often brought forward as proofs of the Trinity. But in neither
of them is it stated that the Son is God, or that the Holy Spirit is a
person, or that these three are the one supreme God. That these passages
should be constantly quoted as proofs of the doctrine of the Trinity shows
that no real proof-texts of the doctrine can be found in the New Testament.
They may seem to imply it to one who already believes that doctrine; but
to those who do not already believe it they appear as a summary of the
truth which proceeds from the Father, the only true God,‹through Jesus
Christ, his holy child and the mediator of his love,‹and made part of the
soul and life by the inward influence of the Divine Spirit.
(d) Because there are many texts in the New Testament plainly opposed to
the Church doctrine of the Trinity.
Such are the texts in which the Father is called
the one or only God; which could not be said if the Son is also God, and
the Holy Spirit God. 1 Cor. viii. 5, 6: "For though there
be that are called gods, whether in heaven or in earth, (as there are gods
many and lords many,) but to us there is one God, the Father:" Eph.
iv. 6: "One God and Father of all, who is above all, and through
all, and in you all." John xvii. 3: Jesus prays to the Father, saying,
"Father! the hour is come!" and immediately adds, "This is life eternal,
that they might know thee the only true God." Eph. v. 20.
The Apostle directs the Ephesians to give "thanks always, for all things,
in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, to God, even the Father" (Revised
Version.) If the Son were God, and the Holy Ghost God, it would
be our duty to pray to them also. But all prayers are commanded to
be addressed to the Father. See Matt. vi. 9; John iv.
23, xvi. 23.
(e) Because we know when and where the doctrine of the Trinity began,
and how it gradually took form.
In the famous Proem
to his Gospel John opposes the idea that the Logos, or Word, was anything
different from God himself. The Word, he tells us, is God speaking,
first, in creation,‹ "By him," God speaking, "were all things made." He
refers here, no doubt, to the common phrases of the Old Testament,‹God
said, "Let there be light;" "The Word of the Lord came to Isaiah;" etc.
Secondly, the Word is God speaking in the soul,‹"That was the true light
which lighteth every man that cometh into the world." Thirdly, the Word
is God revealed in Jesus,‹"The Word was made flesh and dwelt among us."
He thus teaches that as God speaks in creation and speaks in the human
reason, he also speaks in Jesus more clearly and fully. But, as if
to obviate the possibility of being under stood to say that Christ was
God when he really says that God is in Christ, he adds, "No man hath SEEN
God at any time."
This conception of
Christ as a Logos, or Word of God, or a revelation of God, continued to
be taught down to the time of the Synod of Nice (A.D. 325).
The Apostles' Creed, which in its substance goes back to a very early Christian
period, contains no trace of the doctrine of the Trinity. It calls
God "the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth." The Nicene Creed,
in its original form, knows nothing of the Trinity. It calls Jesus
"God," but speaks of him as God of God, meaning "God derived from God,"
and so makes his divinity derived and dependent. And it was not till
the year 380, after much controversy and party strife, that the doctrine
of the Trinity was established in the Church. In the year 383 Theodosius
the Emperor threatened to punish all who did not accept this doctrine.
JESUS CHRIST. * *
§ 19. Unitarians
believe Jesus to be a created being, finite and not infinite, and therefore
below the Supreme Being in his nature and person. Some, called Arians,
think him to have been created before all other finite beings; but this
view is held by few, and seems to have been only a transition belief.
It is supported by a few texts which call Christ "the first-born of every
creature," the being by whom all things were created, etc. (Col.
i. 15, 16). These texts, however, seem to require a different
explanation in order to make them consistent with the numerous other passages
in which the same writer calls Christ "the man Christ Jesus" (I Tim.
ii. 5). Unitarians therefore generally hold Jesus to be a man,
human in soul and body; or, as the Epistle to the Hebrews expresses it,
"in all things it behooved him to be made like unto his brethren" (Heb.
Some Unitarians believe
that though Jesus was a man, entirely human in mind and body, yet that
he was an exceptional man, made free from sin and kept so by an exceptional
Divine influence, made perfect in all spiritual and moral attributes, that
he might be the leader of his race. In this view he was endowed with
supernatural gifts by which he was distinguished from other men.
Other Unitarians hold
that Jesus was not so much an exceptional as a representative man, such
a man as all are intended to be. In this sense he is the ideal man.
In their view sin is not natural, but unnatural, and a sinless man is more
truly a man than is a sinner. They also believe that all men will
grow up into the stature of Jesus, and become like him, so that he will
be the first-born among many brethren. They contend that the typical
man is not the imperfect, but the perfect man, just as the typical plant
or animal of any species is not an imperfect but a perfect specimen.
Any other view, say they, takes us back to the doctrine of natural depravity.
§ 20. As
the Scriptures frequently call Jesus the Son of God, but never call him
God the Son, Unitarians believe him to have been the Son in the sense of
an intimate union with God and dependence on him. When
Jesus said, "I and my Father are one" (John x. 30), he must have
meant one in sympathy, not one in essence; since he prayed (John xvii.
11) that his disciples might be one even as he and the Father were one.
He certainly could not have intended to ask that his disciples might be
one in essence.
§ 21. Unitarians
believe that the great glory of Jesus is his spiritual and moral glory.
His true greatness was in his devotion to the Divine will, his sympathy
with suffering man, his readiness to perform the lowliest offices and bear
a death of shame in order to save mankind from the power and evil of sin.
All this is continually expressed in the New Testament, in passages similar
to that in Philippians ii. 5-11. In this place the Apostle
exhorts his disciples to have the same mind that was in Jesus; who, being
the chief manifestation in the world of the Divine character, did not ambitiously
grasp at the honor of that high dignity but was willing to die the death
of a slave in the service of humanity; and he adds: "Wherefore God also
hath highly exalted him, and given him a name which is above every name:
that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow . . .
and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the
glory of God the Father." This passage, often quoted as a proof-text by
Trinitarians, is an argument for Unitarian views of Jesus. For, while
it attributes to him the highest honors, it states that these are all given
to him by God, that he is exalted by God, and that this great authority
is "to the glory of God the Father." And it also ascribes the origin of
all this glory, not to the divine nature of Jesus, but to his humility
§ 22. Though
Unitarians do not believe it right to call Jesus God, they see no objection
to the epithet "divine." He was a divine man, not a human God. All
agree that he revealed God as Father, as Love, as Infinite Goodness, as
perfect Providence. He was the image of the unseen God; he was the
Word of God uttered to the world; he who has seen him has seen the Father;
he is the well beloved Son, dwelling in the bosom of the Father; God dwells
in him, and he in God. All these expressions teach the intimate union
of his soul with the Infinite Spirit, an intimacy which he desired to communicate
to all his fellow-men. Let us notice that in the New
Testament almost every Divine attribute claimed for Jesus is also claimed
for his disciples. Was he said to "know all things"? It is also said
to them, "Ye have an unction from the Holy One, and ye know all things"
(I John ii. 20). Is it said that he was "without sin"? It is
also said of them, "Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; and he
cannot sin because he is born of God." Did Christ work miracles? He says
of the believer. "Greater works than these shall he do." Did God
give to Christ a glory which he had before the world was? He says of his
disciples "The glory which thou gavest me, I have given them." Did he rise
from the dead to a higher life? Paul says: "If ye then be risen with Christ,
seek those things that are above;" and "As we have borne the image of the
earthy, we shall also bear the image of the heavenly." Did Christ come
to judge the world? It is said of the disciples, "Know ye not that the
saints shall judge the world?" Did God dwell in Christ? It is written of
his followers, "Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the
Spirit of God dwelleth in you?"
The Scripture thus
teaches that (1) all that Christ had, he received from God and (2) that
all he received, he received in order to impart it to his fellow- men.
§ 23. Unitarians
therefore believe in Jesus as a man raised up to be the mediator to his
fellow-men of the divine life; but they do not believe that he was God,‹
(a) Because Jesus always speaks of himself as a man, and is always so spoken
of in Scripture. (b) Because we find no account in Scripture
that a revelation of his divinity was ever made to the disciples.
They regarded their
Master as a man, but wiser and better than themselves. We should
surely have found in the New Testament some trace of the astonishment and
awe which must have come upon them if the wonderful fact had been communicated
to them that their Master was the Supreme God.
(c) Because we find no opposition made by the Jews to this doctrine.
Nothing could have seemed more abhorrent to the Jewish mind than to be
told that Jesus was the Supreme Jehovah. On one occasion they falsely
bring the charge that Jesus, being a man, made himself God (John x.
33). Jesus, instead of saying, "Yes! I am God," answers by quoting
a passage in the Old Testament, where those to whom the word of God came
were called gods, and then says that he had only called himself the Son
of God. After this no such charge was made by the Jews. We
find many accusations made against the Apostles, but they are never charged
with calling their Master the Supreme God. They were only commanded
not to teach in the name of Jesus (Acts iv. 18, v. 40).
(d) Because Jesus plainly distinguishes himself from God. See
John xiii. 3, xvi. 27; Mark x. 18; Matt. xxvii.
46; John xvii. 7.
(e) Because God is called the God of Jesus Christ. See 2 Cor.
xi. 31; Eph. i. 3, 17; Rom. xv. 6; 1 Pet.
i. 3; Heb. i. 2, 9. (f) Because the
Scriptures teach that there is one God, who is distinct from the Christ.
See 1 Cor. viii. 6; I Tim. ii. 5; Eph. iv.
(g) Because the highest powers and glory ascribed to Christ are
said to be given to him by God. See Phil.
ii. 9; Col. i. 19; Acts ii. 36, iii. 13,
v. 31; Matt. xxviii. 18; John v. 19; Eph.
i. 22; etc.
(h) Because Jesus himself teaches his subordination to God.
See John xiv. 28; Matt. xx. 23; Mark xiii. 32;
John x. 29.
(i) Because Jesus prayed to God. See Luke vi.
12; Matt. xi. 25; Luke xxii. 42: Heb. v.
7. (j) Because he commands us to pray, not to himself,
but to God. See John iv. 23, xvi. 23; Luke
xi. 1, 2.
FAITH AND BELIEF IN REGARD TO CHRIST.
§ 24. Faith
in Christ is trusting in him as a revelation of truth and love. Jesus
says, "Ye believe in God, believe also in me" (John xiv. l ).
§ 25. Jesus
asked men to believe in him because he knew that he clearly saw the way
to help them. If they would only trust in him, he would give them
comfort and peace, put their feet in the right path, and enable them to
conquer their sins. If we have faith in the wise, the
good, the noble, the generous, we also become wiser, nobler, more generous;
and as Christ is the wisest and most generous soul that we have ever known,
faith in him is the strongest influence of all. His great hope of
the coming of a kingdom of heaven on earth has inspired his disciples to
overcome the evils of the world. His faith in the fatherly love of
God has brought comfort to the sorrowful and the unfortunate. His
faith in the triumph of good over evil has filled the world with a living
§ 26. Besides
faith in Jesus there is a belief about him. We form this belief by
study and reason. The good of having a distinct belief is that it
saves us from doubt, hesitation, and confusion of mind.
§ 27. Unitarians
believe that the four Gospels contain an adequate historical account of
the life, teaching, and character of Jesus. They believe him to be
the Christ, or King, not in the sense of a Jewish king, but as one who
is to be the master of the world by the power of the truth which he taught.
That he himself held this view appears from John xviii. 37: "To this
end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should
bear witness unto the truth." Unitarians, generally, believe that Jesus
wrought wonderful works of healing, but that it is possible that some of
the accounts in the Gospels may have been imperfectly reported. There
are Unitarians who reject the miraculous element in the Gospels and yet
believe in the leadership of Jesus.
§ 28. It
is objected to Unitarians that they differ from each other so widely in
opinion as to have no common creed. Roman Catholics make the same
objection against the whole Protestant Church. But God has so made
the human mind that as soon as men really begin to think they begin to
differ. If, therefore, there is no difference of opinion in a church,
it shows that there is no individual thought in that church. Men
think alike only by not thinking at all. This is assent, not conviction.
Such belief is, in reality, no belief, and has no value. The only
agreement in opinion which is worth anything is that harmony which comes
after full and free inquiry about subjects on which men differ. Only
thus can questions be really settled; without such free discussion differences
are only covered up. The variety of opinions among Unitarians is
therefore the evidence of free thought.
THE WORK OF CHRIST.
§ 29. Unitarians
believe that Jesus felt himself to be sent by God to reveal his truth (John
xviii. 37) and pardoning love (John i. 17; Matt. ix.
2, 6); to seek and save the lost (Matt. xviii. I l; Luke xix.
10); to give rest to the weary and heavy laden (Matt. xi. 28);
to carry up to a higher morality the law of duty (Matt. v.
18. 20, 21, 27, 33, 39, 44); to sacrifice himself for the good of
others (Matt. xx. 28): to call sinners to repentance (Mark
ii. 17); to preach good news to the poor. freedom to the captives,
sight to the blind, and comfort to the sorrowful (Luke iv. 18, vii.
22); to reveal the Fatherly love of God (Matt. xi. 27; John
xvii. 26); and to give spiritual life and a sense of immortality
to mankind (John vi. 40, 47; John x. 10). Among Unitarians
there are sometimes differing explanations of these texts; but all agree
that the essential mission of Christ is to make men better, wiser, and
happier in this world and in that which is to come.
§ 30. Unitarians
believe it the chief work of Christ to save men from sin and evil here.
They do not believe it his chief work to save them from the consequences
of sin hereafter. He comes to take them out of a present hell, and
lead them into a present heaven.
§ 31. Christ
saves us from the power of sin by his teaching, his life, and his sufferings.
By his teaching he shows us that right and wrong are rooted in the very
nature of things and in the laws of the universe. See
the passages where Jesus states the laws of moral consequence in human
life. Examples: "Whosoever shall exalt himself shall be abased; and
he that shall humble himself shall be exalted." "Blessed are the pure in
heart, for they shall see God." "It is more blessed to give than to receive."
"With what judgment ye judge ye shall be judged." "Every good tree bringeth
forth good fruit." "The tree is known by its fruit." In all such passages
Jesus is stating the working of ever lasting laws.
§ 32. While
the teaching of Jesus manifests the duty and expediency of right doing,
his example shows the possibility, reality, and beauty of a life given
to the service of God and man. "I have given you an example
that ye should do as I have done unto you." "Let this mind be in you which
was also in Christ Jesus," etc. (Phil. ii. 5).
"Except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the Scribes
and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven" (Matt.
v. 20). "Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine,
and doeth them, l will liken him unto a wise man which built his house
upon a rock" (Matt. vii. 24).
§ 33. Jesus
also saves us from the power of sin by his sufferings, in which are included
not only his death, but his sacrifices and endurance during his life.
His principal suffering was probably from the sight of human sin and all
the misery occasioned by it. His sympathy was with the lowest and
humblest of mankind. Living in the full light of the love of God,
he devoted himself to the service of man, and especially of the weak and
sinful. He thus becomes a manifestation of the love of God, and gives
us faith in the Divine goodness and grace offered to every child.
THE HOLY SPIRIT.
§ 34. Unitarians
do not believe the Holy Spirit to be a separate person in the Godhead,
but to be the influence of God's spirit on the human soul, to give strength,
peace, light, love. It is said to be poured out, shed abroad, given,
etc.; which expressions apply to an influence, but not to a person.
§ 35. Unitarians
believe this influence to be given by a constant operation, wherever the
human heart is prepared and ready to receive it. Therefore Christians
are told to "live in the Spirit," to "walk in the Spirit," and the Spirit
is said to "dwell in them." It is given not only to Prophets and Apostles,
to saints and martyrs, but to all who desire help to lead better lives.
§ 36. The
difference between the influence of the Spirit of God and other influences
which come from him is this,‹that whereas the others come to us from without,
through nature, events, and our fellow-men, the influence of the Spirit
is God speaking to us within the soul. We commune with God outwardly
through his works and through the events of our earthly life. We
commune with him inwardly when we are by ourselves, and when in the secret
chamber of our hearts we lift up our thoughts and wishes, our sorrows and
sins, to our Heavenly Father.
UNITARIAN BELIEF CONCERNING MAN.
§ 37. Unitarians
commonly believe that in all men there are religious capacities, by which
they may come into communion with God. These are reason, conscience,
freedom, love of truth, of beauty, of goodness, the sense of the infinite,
the capability of disinterested love; and the kindred sentiments of veneration,
awe, aspiration, etc. These are found, more or less developed, in
all men, and where properly educated and unfolded make the true dignity
and worth of human nature. It is said (Rom. i.
19, 20) that all men have a sufficient knowledge of God to enable them
to obey and love him; and in Rom. ii. 14, that the heathen
who never had a revealed moral law "do by nature the things contained in
the law." The case of Cornelius the Roman (Acts x. I ) leads Peter
to say that good men, in all nations, are acceptable to God (Acts x.
34). See also such passages as the Beatitudes, where the blessings
of Christianity are promised to the meek, the humble, the pure in heart,
§ 38. Unitarians
reject the Calvinistic doctrines of original sin and total depravity, the
responsibility of the human race for Adam's fall, and the belief that,
until converted, man is under the wrath of God. They maintain, on
the contrary, that if there is hereditary depravity, there is also inherited
goodness: that such phrases as "the wrath of God" are figurative, and cannot
apply to the Eternal Goodness. They believe that inherited evil is
misery, but not guilt, and is what Paul refers to when he says, twice over,
of involuntary wrong-doing, "Now it is no more I that do it, but sin that
dwelleth in me" (Rom. vii. 17, 20).
That man in
his natural state has the power to do right, and that such right doing
is well pleasing to God, appears from such passages as these: The parable
of the Sower, where the seed (the Word) falls into "the good ground" of
"an honest and good heart" (Luke viii. 15); the passages which teach
that the spirits of little children see God, face to face (Matt.
xviii. 10, xix. 14); the parable of the Good Samaritan and
that of the Pharisee and Publican (Luke x. 30, xviii. 9), where
the good qualities of heretics and outsiders are commended by Christ.
And see especially the account of the Day of Judgment, where the heathen
who did good actions without having heard of Christ are placed among his
§ 39. When
Unitarians speak of "the dignity of human nature," they do not mean the
dignity of man in his actual condition, but of man as God means him to
be and has made him to become. We find in all men powers and faculties
which unite them with eternity no less than with time. We have within
us reason, which is capable of seeking and finding the noblest truths.
We have conscience, which shows us the difference between right and wrong.
We have the power of freedom, by which we can choose good and refuse evil.
We have the sense of the beautiful, the true, and the good; and a longing
for what is unchanging and eternal. These powers, which are in all
men, constitute the dignity of human nature, and make it capable of perpetual
ATONEMENT AND RECONCILIATION.
§ 40. Unitarians
believe that atonement and reconciliation are the same thing. Both
mean a state of union and peace between man and God; the harmony between
the Divine justice and Divine mercy; and the substitution of trust toward
God and dependence on him, for fear and the dread of his displeasure.
§ 41. Unitarians
do not believe that Christ came to reconcile God to man, but to reconcile
man to God; not to make God love us, but to reveal his love; not to harmonize
his justice and mercy, but to show that they are always in harmony.
Christ's death was not a sacrifice made to appease the Divine anger, but
it was an expression of the Divine love. Paul says (Rom. viii.
32), "He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all,
how shall he not with him also freely give us all things?"
CONVERSION AND REGENERATION.
§ 42. "Conversion"
is the translation of a Greek word which in the New Testament means "to
turn round." When we are going the wrong way, we must turn round in order
to go the right way. Religious conversion is almost the same thing
as repentance. When we are conscious that we are not obeying the
truth and not doing our duty, we need to turn round and to enter at once
upon a new path. This is conversion; and this act may become necessary
many times in the course of our life.
§ 43. "Regeneration"
is the Scripture word used to signify the new life which has its source
not only in the sight of God's law but also in that of God's love.
Then, when we come to see the love of God in all things, we are born again
and become new creatures. We can turn away from our sins, but we
cannot create for ourselves the new heavens and the new earth of spiritual
joy and love. They are revealed to us. in the soul, by a Divine
man is one who has determined to do right and has begun to do right.
The regenerate man is one in whom the habit of right- doing is established,
‹ one who has come to love it, and to whom it is no effort.
§ 44. Prayer
is turning to God and speaking to him in full confidence that he will listen
to us. This is the heart of prayer. An active, hopeful reliance
on God so opens the soul that his life flows in and gives us strength.
Jesus says, "Ask. and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find;
knock, and it shall be opened unto you: for every one that asketh receiveth;
and he that seeketh findeth; and to him that knocketh it shall be opened"
(Matt. vii. 7, 8).
When the disciples
came to their Master, and said, "Lord, teach us to pray," his answer was
in the words which we to this day call the "Lord's Prayer" (Luke xi.
2-4). The first preparation for prayer is to wish to love and to
serve God. If we do not find this desire in our hearts, we must examine
ourselves to see what is wrong in our will, and we should ask God to help
us to a right state of mind and heart.
To pray aright
we must be sincere. Jesus says, "God is a spirit; and they that worship
him must worship him in spirit and in truth" (John iv. 24).
We must not say with our lips the prayer which we do not feel with our
hearts. When we are happy our joy may overflow to the Heavenly Friend
trom whom all our bless ings come; when we are unhappy we may pray to the
same loving Friend for comfort. When we are away from God we must
pray to be brought back again; and when we have sinned we shall find no
peace until we have asked our Father to forgive us and to help us to be
again his obedient children.
§ 45. Objects
of Prayer‹The chief objects of prayer are spiritual. We ask God for
strength, peace, purity, love,‹ that is, for the Holy Spirit. We
know that to do any duty effectually it should be done in the right spirit.
But we cannot always obtain a right spirit by an effort of the will.
We may be depressed, or anxious, or vexed, or irritated. In that
case this bad spirit will go into our words and actions, and prevent us
from exercising the good influence we really have at heart. But if
we open our soul to God, and ask him to help us to feel right in order
to do right, we may be sure that this help will come.
May we also ask for outward blessings? Some good and wise persons think
that we ought not. They consider it selfish to do so, and they also
believe that this is asking God to suspend the action of his universal
laws. Others, however, say that we may ask God for anything we desire,
and that God wishes to have us do so; just as a good father and mother
like to have their children bring to them all the wishes of their heart.
Only, in such cases, we must ask in submission, as Jesus did, "Nevertheless,
not as I will, but as thou wilt" (Matt. xxvi. 39). We
must also ask "in his name." This, however, does not mean repeating the
words "through Jesus Christ," as though these words might have some magical
power. But "the name of Christ" means the spirit of Christ.
We must ask in Christ's spirit, not selfishly, but including the good of
others in our prayer.
§ 46. Times
of Prayer.‹It may be well to have some fixed times for prayer, ‹for example,
the beginning of the day, when we are about to resume the duties of life,
and need to go to them in a right spirit; and at the close of the day.
when we may look back and thank God for what he has helped us to be and
do. and ask his forgiveness for our failures. It is also desirable
to pray, even for a moment, before any work which requires preparation
that it may be done aright.
§ 47. Answer
to Prayer.‹Some Unitarians believe that the only answer to prayer is the
good influence which the thought of God's presence exercises on the soul.
In this sense prayer is the same as contemplation, or meditation.
Others, however, believe that by a law of the Divine government prayer
puts the soul into such a relation with God that we can receive a direct
influence from him. This law requires us to ask as the condition
of receiving some special blessing, which we should not be in a condition
to receive unless we pray for it. This makes a real communion between
God and the soul.
§ 48. Unitarians
believe that the Church is a union of those who come together to help each
other to live a Christian life. The essential character of a church
is stated by Jesus when he says, "Where two or three are gathered together
in my name, there am I in the midst of them" (Matt. xviii.
l9, 20). To meet "in the name of Christ" is to meet in his spirit,
to do his work. To pray "in his name" is to pray in the same spirit
in which he prayed. "In the name of a prophet, or righteous man"
(Matt. x. 41) means in a spirit of sympathy with the prophet
or righteous man. The Jews laid more stress on a name than we do.
We regard it as an accidental appendage; they gave names as indicating
§ 49. Unitarians
believe that the work of the Church is to reform the vicious, to educate
the ignorant, to strengthen the weak, and to co-operate in all attempts
to elevate and improve society. For this reason they look forward
to the time when all churches shall unite together in the purpose of doing
good, so that at last God's kingdom may come, and his will be done on earth
as it is in heaven.
§ 50. Unitarians
generally accept the two ordinances of Baptism and the Lord's Supper, not
as essential to spiritual life, but as helps to it. They regard both,
not as ends, but as means. They consider them as natural symbols
and outward images of inward feeling and purpose. If practised merely
as forms, without this inward application, their value is gone.
§ 51. Baptism,
or the external application of water, expresses the desire that the infant
or adult baptized may be surrounded by those outward Christian influences
which conduce to purity of character and conduct. Water is the natural
symbol of purity. When Jesus washed the feet of his disciples he
expressed this thought, and added that the disciples also ought to wash
each other's feet,‹that is, that they ought to help each other to put away
the defilements of sin. In baptizing infants, Unitarians
do not intend to express a belief that this outward act can have any effect
on the soul of the child. No Unitarian accepts the doctrine of Regeneration
by Baptism in any such sense as this. But by this rite we express
our belief that the infant is already dear to God, and we baptize him as
an expression of our wish that he may have the help which comes from union
with the Christian Church, and our desire that his parents and all others
may be faithful in surrounding him with Christian influences, and educating
him in the Christian life.
§ 52. The
Lord's Supper, or the partaking of bread and wine in company, is a sign
of Christian brotherhood. It also symbolizes the inward influences
of Christianity, as Baptism is a type of the outward influence. Bread
was the type of strength, and wine of joy. The Lord's Supper is a
feast of communion, or brotherhood. It also recalls to us the death
of Christ for the good of all mankind. It is thus a feast of remembrance,
and has a tendency to produce and maintain a living sense of our personal
relation to Jesus as a teacher and friend. To eat his flesh and drink
his blood signifies, in Oriental language, to make his teaching and character
a part of our own life. Unitarians usually invite all those who desire
to remember Jesus to unite with them in this service. They do not
consider it intended for members of the church only, or only for professing
Christians, but for all who love Jesus and wish to express their love by
communion with his friends . These two ordinances of
the Christian Church, having been continued from the beginning, unite successive
generations of Christians with each other as well as with their common
53. Unitarians in New England, having originated among the Congregationalists,
are independent in their form of church government, and are therefore called
Congregationalists. Each church is independent of others, though
ready to unite with them in work and sympathy. For these purposes
they meet from time to time in local Conferences and in a National Conference.
In other places, where Unitarian beliefs came up among the Presbyterians,
as in the North of Ireland, or among the Methodists, as in the Western
States. Unitarians retain some of the methods of church government
belonging to these other denominations.
§ 54. A creed
(from the Latin "credo," I believe) is simply a belief. In this sense
creeds are good, useful, and desirable for individuals. If two or
three who hold the same belief unite to convince others of its truth, this
also is natural and right. If they state their creed in propositions
and articles, this also may be useful. To such creeds Unitarians
do not object. Many of their churches have adopted such statements
§ 55. But
Unitarians object to religious creeds under the following circumstances:
1. When they are made a test of character; 2. When they are
made a condition of fellowship; 3. When they become an obstacle to
progress. Most of the creeds of the Christian Church
have been liable to these objections. They have been made a test
of Christian character, contrary to the distinct statement of Jesus that
obedience, not belief, or profession, is the true test of character (Matt.
vii. 15-27), and that true religion consists in love to God and man
(Mark xii. 28-34). They have been made a condition of Christian
fellow ship, contrary to the declaration of Jesus that whosoever shall
do the will of God is like a mother and sister and brother to him (Mark
iii. 35). They have been an obstacle to progress, imposing
the opinions of past centuries upon present belief. Though Unitarians
reject such creeds as these, their religious convictions are not the less
distinct and earnest.
LIBERAL AND RATIONAL CHRISTIANITY.
§ 56. Liberal
Christianity, or freedom in religion, does not mean liberty to believe
what we choose, but freedom to seek the truth anywhere, everywhere, and
always. It means that we should not only be willing that others should
differ from us, but ready to help them to inquire freely, even if their
inquiries lead them to believe what we consider erroneous. It means
that we are not to judge each other (Matt. vii. 1-5; Rom.
xiv. 1-23), nor to submit our own belief to the judgment of any church
or any human authority.
§ 57. Rational
Christianity does not mean that we are to reject all beliefs which we do
not now see to be reasonable, or to make reason the only source of truth.
But it means that we are to test every belief by the light of our reason,
and seek to understand clearly what we think and why we think it.
§ 58. Unitarians
believe that the whole duty of man consists in doing justly, loving mercy,
and walking humbly with God (Micah vi. 8); in loving God whith all
the heart, and one's neighbor as one's self (Matt. xxii. 37-39).
They believe that the essence of religion is goodness; that "the pure in
heart see God" that whoever heareth Christ's sayings and doeth them has
built his house upon a rock (Matt. vii. 24). They believe
that if we have an earnest desire to lead a good life we may trust in the
promise that "he who hungers and thirsts after righteousness shall be filled;"
and that if we are ready, when we fail. to repent, confess, and forsake
our sin, "God is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse
us from all unrighteousness" ( I John i. 9).
§ 59. We
believe that the really good man is in the way of salvation, whatever may
be his outward form of religion. Mere surface morality, not rooted
in principle, we do not call goodness. But whoever seeks to do the
will of God, and to be faithful and just to man, whether he be heathen
or Christian, we believe vvill be accepted by God, the Father of all mankind
(Acts x. 35; Matt. xxv. 34-41 Rom. ii. 14-16).
§ 60. Unitarians
regard goodness as the end, and religious acts as the means and helps to
that end. Inward goodness of the heart expressed by outward good
ness in life is primary and essential. Religion is for the sake of
goodness, and belongs not only to the Church and to Sunday, but to every
place and to all times. It must go with us to our home, to our place
of work, to our amusements and be the help and strength of every day.
Religion is given to make all of life sacred; to sanctify business, politics,
pleasure, work, and all our intercourse with each other.
THE FUTURE LIFE.
§ 61. Unitarians
believe that the future life will be a continuation of the present life,
with opportunity for further growth and development. They think that
every man will go "to his place,"‹the place where he belongs, the place
where it is best for him to be. Jesus says, "In my Father's house
are many mansions; if it were not so I would have told you" (John xiv.
§ 62. According
to the New Testament outward death‹what we call death ‹is nothing; it is
merely the soul laying down its present instruments in order to take up
others. The only real death is the soul's death; that is, sin, ignorance,
unbelief. The soul which lives in sin is dead in its higher faculties.
Christ comes to raise us out of this spiritual death into spiritual life;
and then we say, "The law of the spirit of life, in Christ Jesus, hath
made me free from the law of sin and death" (Rom. viii. 2).
The Apostle says that Jesus has "abolished death" (2 Tim. i.
10); and Christ says of himself, "I am the resurrection and the life' (John
xi. 25). The truth and love and influence of Christ are the
resurrection of the soul, just as they are the life of the soul.
The resurrection is spiritual resurrection, as the life is spiritual life.
When Jesus says, "And this is the will of him that sent me, that every
one which seeth the Son and believeth on him may have everlasting life,
and I will raise him up at the last day" (John vi. 40), he does not
speak of the resurrection of the body, but of the principle of spiritual
life which he communicates to the soul.
When we believe
that God cares for us, that he loves us, we are free from the fear of death.
We trust ourselves entirely to our faithful Creator, and say, "Into thy
hands, O Lord, l commit my spirit," sure that when with him we are always
PROBATION, JUDGMENT, AND RETRIBUTION.
§ 63. We
often hear it said that this life is a state of probation; but we believe
it to resemble rather a school, where we are to be educated for a better
and higher life hereafter. The trials and sorrows of this life are
a wholesome discipline, meant to unfold and strengthen the powers of the
soul. We are to learn here the difference between right and wrong,
between truth and error,‹learn to form habits of goodness, learn to love
and trust God, learn to live with our fellow-men as brethren. To
do this, we must often examine and prove ourselves, and thus find out our
strength and our weakness. In this sense life can be said to be a
period of probation. God does not need to prove us to find out what
we are. "All things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with
whom we have to do" (Heb. iv. 13).
§ 64. The
Judgments to come, like the Judgments of this life, are probably different
for each individual soul. The Day of Judgment arrives when any one
comes to know himself as he really is, and is seen by others in his true
character. Our conscience demands a Divine judgment on all human
conduct and character; not so much that the good shall be rewarded and
the wicked punished, as that goodness which has been misunderstood shall
be justified, and that wicked ness which has passed for goodness shall
be exposed; that wrongs shall be righted, and that men shall see the justice
of God. It is also necessary for a man's own moral progress that
he shall be undeceived if he is deceiving himself. But just so far
as a man is able to see his sin here, and is ready to confess it and to
repent of it, so far he makes the judgments of the future life less necessary
for him. Therefore it is said, "If we would judge ourselves we should
not be judged" (1 Cor. xi. 31). "If we confess our sins,
he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from
all unrighteousness" (1 John i. 9). In John v. 22 it
is said, "The Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment unto
the Son." Elsewhere Christ says, "I judge no man" (John viii. 15).
These passages are harmonized by the saying of Jesus, "The word that I
have spoken, the same shall judge him in the last day" (John xii.
48). The truth which Christ taught is to be our standard, and by
it we shall be judged. The essential thing in the judgment
to come we believe to be the manifestation of truth to every man's conscience
in the sight of God,‹ to see ourselves as we are, and God as he is.
§ 65. Unitarians
believe that future retribution comes from the operation of the same laws
which produce retribution here. By the everlasting principles of
Divine Providence, right-doing tends to moral health, peace, and spiritual
growth; wrong-doing, to moral disease and suffering. These laws are
beneficent in their operation in this world and in all worlds. All
punishment is intended to reform us and to do us good. This principle
of the Divine government is expressed in Heb. xii. 10, where
it is said that the Father of spirits chastens us "for our profit, that
we might be partakers of his holiness."
HEAVEN AND HELL.
§ 66. Unitarians
do not believe that hereafter there will be two distinct and separate worlds,‹
one for the good and the other for the wicked,‹the one of perfect unchanging
happiness, the other of entire and unchanging misery. The "great
gulf" (Luke xvi. 26) between the good and the bad man in this and
in all worlds consists in the everlasting distinction between good and
evil. So long as one is in the hell of selfish desire and will, no
consoling drop of heavenly content can be brought to him. Unitarians
believe in many hells and many heavens, according to the character and
condition of each person. They believe that the purpose of future
suffering will be reformatory and not vindictive; and that if a man is
selfish and wilful, it is best for him to suffer the consequences of these
evils in order to become better.
§ 67. Unitarians
oppose the common doctrine of everlasting punishment as being hostile to
the sovereignty, wisdom, justice, and mercy of the Divine Being, and also
as limiting the redeeming power of Christ and his Gospel. They believe
that, the object of punishment being reformatory, it will only continue
until the sinner shall be reformed.
If it be said
that we have no right to reason from human justice and mercy to that of
God, we answer, 1. That all we know of justice must come from the
principle of justice implanted in the human consciousness by God himself;
2. That Jesus himself compares the love of the Heavenly Father with
the love of the earthly parent, and shows us from an example of imperfect
goodness what we may believe that the Divine goodness will do for us (Matt.
of everlasting punishment tends to destroy faith in the redeeming and conquering
power of the Gospel; for in that we are taught that goodness is stronger
than evil, that love is able to conquer all sin, and that it is the pleasure
of the Father to reconcile all things on the earth or in heaven to himself
by Jesus Christ (Col. i. 20).
When Jesus declared
(Luke xv. 7) that "joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth
more than over ninety and nine just persons which need no repentance,"
he implied that the grief in heaven over one lost soul would outweigh the
joy over ninety and nine that are saved, and that even the angels cannot
be happy while one sinner turns himself away from the love which is waiting
to bless him.
* In this definition
of reason is followed the school of thought represented by such writers
as Coleridge, Victor Cousin, and Dr. James Walker, who distinguished
"reason," the higher intellectual faculty, from "reasoning, ' a function
of the lower understanding.&#
* We follow
the custom in saying Jesus Christ, though it would be more correct always
to say Jesus the Christ. Christ, or Messiah. is not a proper
name, but the name of an office.